Home/iPhone Repair/Screen Repair/Screen Types Explained
Screen Repair · Aftermarket vs. OEM

LCD vs. OLED Aftermarket iPhone Screens vs. OEM: What's the Real Difference?

Almost every iPhone screen quote at our counter comes down to one question: which screen goes back in? There are two aftermarket options, LCD and OLED, and two OEM options built on original Apple panels. Here's what each one actually is, what you'll notice day to day, and which one makes sense for your phone.

Book a Free Diagnostic Call (857) 302-2655
$89
Screen Repair Starting Price
4 Grades
Your Choice, Explained Upfront
20–30 Min
In-Stock Grades
Lifetime
Warranty On Touch Issues
Aftermarket LCD, aftermarket OLED, and OEM iPhone replacement screens compared at Fix 'N Repair Massachusetts
Aftermarket LCD, aftermarket OLED, or OEM: the differences show up in black levels, thickness, battery use, and tap to wake.

Start here: which screen did your iPhone come with?

Before comparing grades, it helps to know what Apple put in your phone at the factory. That decides whether a given replacement is a like-for-like swap or a step down.

Shipped with OLED

iPhone XXS / XS Max11 Pro / 11 Pro MaxEvery iPhone 12Every iPhone 13Every iPhone 15Every iPhone 16Every iPhone 17

Shipped with LCD

iPhone XRiPhone 11

If you own an XR or a standard iPhone 11, the OLED question doesn't apply. Those phones were built around an LCD, and there's no OLED part made for them. For everyone else, the choice is real: you can stay with OLED, or save money by going to an LCD-based Incell screen.

How LCD and OLED actually make a picture

LCD (including Incell)

One backlight behind every pixel

  • A light panel sits behind the whole screen and stays on whenever the display is on
  • Liquid crystals block or pass that light to form the image
  • Because the backlight never fully shuts off, black looks dark gray, especially in a dim room
  • The extra backlight layer makes the display stack thicker
  • No burn-in risk
OLED

Every pixel makes its own light

  • Each pixel lights itself, so there's no backlight layer at all
  • A black pixel is simply turned off, which gives true black and high contrast
  • Thinner and lighter than an LCD stack
  • Uses less power on dark content and in dark mode
  • Can show faint burn-in after very long periods of the same static image

Aftermarket LCD, aftermarket OLED, and OEM

"Aftermarket" means a third-party panel. "OEM" means it's built on an original Apple panel. We quote two of each, from most affordable to closest to factory.

1. Aftermarket LCD (Incell)

Kept in stock

An aftermarket LCD where the touch layer is built into the display panel instead of sitting on top as a separate layer. It's the grade behind our $89 starting price, and it's what most budget repairs use.

What you'll notice on an OLED iPhone: grayer blacks, a little less color punch, and a slightly thicker screen. Touch response and everyday use work normally, with one exception below. It's a solid pick for an older phone, a kid's phone, or a phone you're replacing within a year.

Heads up: tap to wake (tapping the screen to light it up) doesn't work on aftermarket screens. You'll wake the phone with the side button or by raising it instead.

2. Aftermarket OLED (soft OLED)

Kept in stock

A third-party OLED panel, so you keep true blacks, the thin profile, and OLED's efficiency on dark screens. We use soft OLED wherever our supplier offers it. Soft OLED is built on a flexible base, the same basic construction as the original. Hard OLED uses a rigid base that's more fragile, and we only use it where nothing else exists, like the iPhone 12 mini.

For most people with an OLED iPhone they plan to keep, this is the grade we point them toward. It costs more than Incell but noticeably less than the original-panel options below.

Heads up: like Incell, aftermarket OLED doesn't support tap to wake. Everything else about touch works as normal.

3. OEM refurbished (Premium)

Ordered for your repair

Built around an original Apple display panel that has been refurbished, rather than a third-party panel. Color, brightness, and fit are closest to what your phone had when it was new, short of a factory service part.

We don't keep these on the shelf for every model, so we order one for your repair. We'll give you the exact price and the lead time before anything is ordered.

4. OEM service pack

Ordered for your repair

The closest thing to the screen Apple installs. It's the most expensive grade, and it makes the most sense on a recent Pro or Pro Max you plan to keep for years or sell later at a higher price.

Like Premium, it's ordered for your specific phone. If you'd rather source a genuine screen directly from Apple, see the self-service option below. Not every model has every grade. For example, there's no aftermarket OLED option for the iPhone 13 mini, so its choices are Incell, Premium, or OEM.

Side by side

How the four grades compare on the things customers actually notice. Exact prices depend on your model, so we confirm them after a free in-store diagnostic.

GradePanelBlacks & contrastBattery on dark screensTap to wakeCostAvailability
Aftermarket LCDThird-party Incell LCDDark gray, lower contrastBacklight always onNoLowestIn stock, 20–30 min
Aftermarket OLEDThird-party soft OLEDTrue blackOLED-efficientNoModerateIn stock, 20–30 min
OEM refurbishedOriginal Apple panel, refurbishedTrue black (OLED models)Same as originalAsk at intakeHigherOrdered per repair
OEM service packOriginal Apple service partTrue black (OLED models)Same as originalAsk at intakeHighestOrdered per repair
About the display notification

On iPhone 11 and newer, iOS shows a notification after a display that isn't a genuine Apple part is installed. It appears on the lock screen for the first few days, then moves into Settings → General → About, where it stays listed. It's informational only. You can't turn it off, but the phone, touch, and display keep working normally. If you'd like to know what to expect on your specific model, ask at intake before you choose.

Which grade should you pick?

There's no single right answer. It depends on how long you're keeping the phone and how much the display quality matters to you. Here's how we usually talk it through at the counter:

  • Older phone, backup phone, or trading it in soon: Incell. It's the most affordable way to get a working, responsive screen back.
  • OLED iPhone you'll keep another two years or more: soft OLED. You keep the look and battery behavior you're used to without paying for an original panel.
  • Recent Pro or Pro Max, or you care most about matching the original: Premium or OEM. Plan for the order time.
  • You want a genuine Apple screen and don't mind waiting: order the part from Apple yourself and have us install it. Details below.
  • iPhone XR or 11: it's LCD either way, so the choice is between Incell and the refurbished original.

Whichever grade you pick, we'll tell you the price and turnaround before we start. Nothing goes in your phone until you say yes. Questions before you come in? Call (857) 302-2655.

Want a genuine Apple screen? Order it from Apple, and we'll install it

If an original screen matters most and you can wait for shipping, you can buy the part yourself through Apple's Self Service Repair store. Once it arrives, bring it to any of our shops and we'll do the installation for a labor-only charge.

  1. Order the display for your exact iPhone model from Apple's Self Service Repair store.
  2. Call us when it arrives at (857) 302-2655 and we'll confirm the labor-only price for your model.
  3. Bring the phone and the part to Watertown, Newton, Burlington, or Wakefield, and we'll install it.

One thing to know: parts you supply aren't covered by our warranty, including Apple parts bought this way. If the part arrives defective, that goes back through Apple. You also keep your phone in one piece until the part shows up, so there's no downtime while you wait.

Price, timing, and warranty

iPhone screen repair starts at $89. Newer models and higher grades cost more, and we confirm the exact number for your phone after a free in-store diagnostic. Incell and soft OLED repairs typically take 20–30 minutes. Walk-ins are first come, first served. For model-by-model details, see our iPhone screen repair page.

Screen replacements carry a lifetime warranty covering:

  • Loss of touch sensitivity
  • Ghost clicking
  • Random clicking
  • Screen lifting

The lifetime warranty does not cover:

  • New drop or impact damage after the repair
  • LCD/OLED panel issues that appear later, such as the screen going black, lines across the display, or black marks and blotches, even with no visible crack
  • Parts you supply yourself

Keep your receipt. A text or email copy is fine for warranty claims. Wondering how the screen cracked in the first place? Read why iPhone screens crack from small drops, or see our full iPhone repair services.

Compare grades in person in Watertown, Newton, Burlington, or Wakefield

Bring your phone to any of our four Massachusetts shops for a free diagnostic, and we'll lay out every grade available for your model with an exact price. Call (857) 302-2655 to check on your model before you come in.

See all four locations and hours →

Frequently asked questions

Is an aftermarket LCD, aftermarket OLED, or OEM screen better?
If your iPhone shipped with OLED, which includes every model from the 12 onward plus the X, XS, XS Max, 11 Pro, and 11 Pro Max, an OLED replacement keeps the true blacks, contrast, and thin profile you're used to. An aftermarket LCD costs less, but blacks look slightly gray and the screen is a bit thicker. OEM screens cost the most and match the original most closely. The XR and standard 11 were built with LCD, so there's no OLED option for them.
What is an Incell screen?
Incell is an aftermarket LCD where the touch layer is built into the display panel itself instead of being a separate layer on top. It's the most affordable grade we install and the one behind our $89 starting price. On an iPhone that originally had OLED, it's a step down in contrast, but touch response and everyday use are normal. It's a good fit for older phones or a phone you plan to replace soon.
What's the difference between soft OLED and hard OLED?
Both are aftermarket OLED panels. Soft OLED is built on a flexible base, the same basic construction Apple uses, so it fits and behaves more like the original. Hard OLED uses a rigid base that's more fragile and can fit slightly differently. We use soft OLED wherever our supplier offers it for your model. The iPhone 12 mini is the exception, since only a hard OLED version is made for it.
Will my iPhone show a message about the new screen?
On iPhone 11 and newer, yes. After a display that isn't a genuine Apple part is installed, iOS shows a notification on the lock screen for the first few days, then keeps it listed under Settings, General, About. It's informational and can't be turned off, but the phone, touch, and display keep working normally. If you'd rather avoid it, ask about ordering a genuine Apple screen through Apple's Self Service Repair store.
Why do OEM screens cost more and take longer?
Both are built around original Apple display panels instead of third-party ones, and those parts cost far more wholesale. We don't keep them on the shelf for every model, so we order one for your specific repair. Incell and soft OLED are the grades we keep on hand for 20 to 30 minute repairs. Before anything is ordered, we give you the exact price and the expected lead time so you can decide.
Does an aftermarket screen drain the battery faster?
An Incell LCD can. LCDs light the whole panel with a backlight whenever the screen is on, while OLED pixels only draw power when they're lit. That makes OLED more efficient on dark screens and in dark mode. If your iPhone originally had OLED and you switch to Incell, you may notice slightly shorter battery life. Going to a soft OLED keeps the same basic power behavior as the original screen.
Does tap to wake work on aftermarket screens?
No. Tap to wake, where you tap the screen to light it up, doesn't work on aftermarket screens, and that includes both Incell LCD and aftermarket soft OLED. You can still wake the phone with the side button or by lifting it if Raise to Wake is on in Settings. Everything else about touch works normally. If tap to wake is a must for you, ask us about the original-panel options before choosing a grade.
Can I buy a genuine Apple screen myself and have you install it?
Yes. You can order a genuine display for your model from Apple's Self Service Repair store, wait for it to ship, and bring it to any of our four shops. We'll install it for a labor-only charge; call (857) 302-2655 for the price on your model. Keep in mind that parts you supply aren't covered by our warranty, so a defective Apple part goes back through Apple, not us.
What does the screen replacement warranty cover?
Our screen replacements carry a lifetime warranty covering loss of touch sensitivity, ghost clicking, random clicking, and screen lifting. It doesn't cover new drop or impact damage after the repair. Separately, it doesn't cover LCD/OLED panel issues that show up later, like the screen going black, lines across the display, or black marks, even with no new crack. Parts you supply yourself aren't covered. Keep your receipt; a text or email copy works.
How much does iPhone screen repair cost?
Screen repair starts at $89 with an Incell screen on older models. The price goes up with newer iPhones and with higher grades like soft OLED, Premium, and OEM. We confirm the exact price for your model and chosen grade after a free in-store diagnostic, before any work starts. Incell and soft OLED repairs typically take 20 to 30 minutes. Call (857) 302-2655 to check pricing for your model.

Not Sure Which Screen to Pick?

Bring your iPhone in for a free diagnostic. We'll show you every grade available for your model, with an exact price, before anything gets installed.

Call Us Now Book a Free Diagnostic

Or call directly: (857) 302-2655

Written by the Fix 'N Repair Team · Based on the screen-grade conversations we have at the counter every week in our Watertown, Newton, Burlington, and Wakefield shops.